Rob Reiner Always Found Heart in the Horror of Stephen King

Stephen King adaptations are notoriously tricky.

With more than seventy novels and novellas to his name, not to mention 200 short stories, the Master of Horror’s expansive catalogue is a tempting sandbox for horror creators. But the success rate is comparably low. What may seem conceptually straightforward — a murderous clown, haunted hotel, or killer car — depends on strong characterization and a believable world. Many directors become sidetracked by supernatural elements or shocking moments of violence and gore while forgetting the emotional engine that drives the story.

Despite his reputation for terrorizing readers, King’s work is surprisingly warm, with powerful sentiment permeating each page. It takes an equally empathetic director to capture the author’s signature blend of horror and heart.  

The son of prominent comedians, Rob Reiner came from a background in improv and won national fame as Michael “Meathead” Stivic on the iconic sitcom All in the Family before stepping behind the camera for the 1984 satire This Is Spinal Tap. Two years later, he set out to tackle one of King’s most tender stories. Stand by Me, an adaptation of the third novella in the 1982 collection Different Seasons, The Body, follows four boys on a quest to locate the corpse of Ray Brower (Kent W. Luttrell), a kid rumored to have been hit by a train. As they traverse the railroad tracks of southern Maine, Gordie (Wil Wheaton), Chris (River Phoenix), Teddy (Corey Feldman), and Vern (Jerry O’Connell) let down their guards and express the pain of transitioning into young adulthood. King based the story on childhood memories, calling The Body his only “nakedly autobiographical story.” 

Though Stand by Me shares DNA with other ’80s adventure films like E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial and The Goonies, Reiner builds his horror from stark reality. Gordie and his friends do not find themselves flying their bikes into the night sky, nor do they evade gangsters in subterranean pirate ships. Instead, they face more relatable danger like a vicious junkyard dog trained to attack and a pond full of blood sucking leeches. The film’s most famous sequence sees the boys dashing across a high trestle to avoid being struck by an oncoming train. Even the body they find is presented with unflinching realism.

This disturbing scene’s horror does not come from graphic special effects or visceral gore, but the inescapable fact of death. The boys stare down at this unremarkable corpse, knowing they will one day find themselves in his shoes.   

Many directors who try to adapt King’s work find themselves bogged down in faithfulness to the text, but Reiner makes a few key alterations. Most prominent is the choice to center the story’s young narrator, Gordie, a clear proxy for King himself. Describing this shift, Reiner said, “In the book, it was about four boys, but…once I made Gordie the central focus of the piece then it made sense to me: this movie was all about a kid who didn’t feel good about himself and whose father didn’t love him.”

The burgeoning writer must navigate the recent loss of his older brother and the knowledge that his parents wish he had died instead. Gordie shares this devastating fear while weeping on the shoulder of his best friend, Chris, who consoles him with a prediction that he will one day be a great writer. Describing this touching moment, the world-famous author remembers, “That weeping boy was me. It was Rob Reiner who put it on the screen.”

Reiner was nervous to show King the film, wary of altering such a personal story. In an interview with the Chicago Tribune, Reiner remembered the author excusing himself for 15 minutes after the credits rolled on a private screening. King returned and gave the director a hug, noting, “That’s the best film ever made out of anything I’ve written, which isn’t saying much. But you’ve really captured my story.” Audiences agreed, and Stand by Me remains a classic coming-of-age drama, often listed among the best works of both creators. 

Based on the success of Stand by Me, Reiner founded Castle Rock Entertainment, named for the setting of The Body and a number of King’s more prominent works. Dedicated to fostering creative freedom, Reiner followed this adaptation with a trio of films under the Castle Rock banner that would each come to exemplify their respective genres. While The Princess Bride, When Harry Met Sally, and A Few Good Men may have little in common by surface standards, each succeeds on the strength of their well-drawn characters and Reiner’s knack for finding humor and heart in the most outlandish situations.

It’s this ability to unearth the emotional core that makes him such a good match for King’s source material. After all, The Body is less about the search for Ray Brower and more about four friends learning to support each other in one of life’s most painful transitions. Another of Reiner’s creative decisions — titling the film Stand by Me — reflects this infectious empathy. While undoubtedly practical, referencing Ben E. King’s emotional ballad shifts the story’s tone from death to life and the beauty of true friendship. 

Reiner would go on to repeat this success with a much more overt horror story that nonetheless hides a complex emotional center. Based on King’s 1987 novel, Misery is an intimate story of obsession and abuse captured in an isolated mountain farmhouse. Paul Sheldon (James Caan) is a romance writer who’s just completed his first “serious work” in years when his car slides off a mountain road in the midst of a heavy blizzard. He’s rescued by Annie Wilkes (Kathy Bates), a former nurse who just happens to be Paul’s biggest fan. At first, this seems too good to be true until he realizes that the unstable woman has no intention of letting him go. Annie holds her favorite author prisoner and forces him to write the next installment in her beloved series of Misery novels.  

Bates is breathtaking as the monstrous Annie, earning one of horror’s few Academy Awards. In a single scene, she careens from gently feeding Paul his lunch to screaming about a childhood frustration, then quickly apologizing for her outburst. Annie becomes increasingly violent as Paul’s injuries begin to heal. She smashes his mangled legs with a ream of typing paper when he dares to ask for a different brand and demands he burn his new manuscript as punishment for killing off her favorite character. And who can forget the famous hobbling scene in which Annie shatters Paul’s feet as punishment for leaving his room?

One of the most painful moments in horror history, the scene represents another significant change to King’s story. In the novel, Annie cuts off Paul’s foot with an ax before quickly cauterizing the stump. Reiner’s version of the character bashes his feet with a massive sledgehammer, while insisting it’s all for his own good. In a marvel of practical effects, we watch as Paul’s foot simply flops to the side. In fact, the impact is so effective that Reiner doesn’t show us the second blow, cutting instead to Caan’s agonizing screams and trusting that our minds will make up the difference. This change reinforces the emotional abuse Annie inflicts on Paul throughout the story while allowing him to survive intact. From the outside, the author appears to be healing, but this brutal scene represents the horror of Annie’s captivity. Her rhapsodic, “God, I love you,” as she basks in Paul’s misery, speaks volumes about the sadistic nurse.

Balancing this gruesome horror, Reiner again adds humor and heart to King’s dark subject matter with Sheriff Buster (Richard Farnsworth) and his wife, Virginia (Frances Sternhagen). Slowly putting the pieces together, the laid-back lawman confronts Annie about Paul’s disappearance while he lies sedated on the basement floor. But along the way, this elderly couple flirt and joke at every turn, providing a sharp contrast to Annie’s toxic devotion. Her infatuation with her favorite writer is an evil funhouse mirror to Virginia’s and Buster’s respectful romance. King has also praised the comedic elements of Bates’ performance, specifically her mispronunciation of Dom Pérignon. “[I]t’s both funny and touching: This woman has never had anyone to teach her the correct pronunciation,” King wrote. “Rob caught that perfectly.”

This would be the last time Reiner would direct a Stephen King adaptation, though Castle Rock would be responsible for a few other hits. In 1987, Frank Darabont was an up-and-coming director with a screenwriting credit on the fan-favorite A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors. He’d previously had success directing a low-budget adaptation of King’s most personal text. “The Woman in the Room” is an early short story based on the author’s experience watching his mother die. Darabont approached King about adapting the first Different Seasons novella, Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption, securing the rights for $5,000. Skeptical that it could be done, King nonetheless approved Darabont’s request and would eventually send back the uncashed check. Darabont spent years reworking the story from a black comedy about a prison escape to a touching parable about hope and redemption. 

Upon completion, Darabont approached Castle Rock with the screenplay, and producer Liz Glotzer was so impressed that she threatened to quit if the company didn’t take on the project. Though Reiner initially wanted to direct, Darabont insisted on helming his own screenplay, hoping to make a name for himself in the industry. Reiner served as a mentor, encouraging him to lean into the characterization that worked so well for his previous King titles. The Shawshank Redemption opened in 1994 to disappointing box office numbers, but an Academy Award nomination for Best Picture raised its profile, leading to a much more successful home video run and cultural reappraisal.

Darabont’s film currently holds the #1 spot on IMDb’s overall rankings and remains one of the most universally beloved movies of all time. The director would go on to adapt The Green Mile (1999) and The Mist (2007), other King stories centering on complex human beings trapped in horrific situations. Alongside these cinematic successes, Castle Rock would also produce Seinfeld, one of the most highly regarded and influential sitcoms of the 20th century, which also happens to be entirely character-driven. 

We’re currently in the midst of another Stephen King renaissance with the dual popularity of Andy Muschietti’s It franchise and Stranger Things, which pulls heavily from the author’s early work. Both of these coming-of-age horror stories can trace their inspiration directly back to The Body and Rob Reiner’s Stand by Me.

In an emotional tribute to the late director, King remembers watching the adaptation for the first time. “I marveled at what a good story the truth could make in the right hands.” Though known for his work in the horror sphere, King has built a genre-bending empire on beloved characters who find heartfelt truth in harrowing fiction. Over the years, Reiner and his equally cherished films demonstrate a similar talent for emotional storytelling. It’s difficult to overstate his influence on the cinematic landscape and his unparalleled ability to capture the heart of Stephen King. 

The post Rob Reiner Always Found Heart in the Horror of Stephen King appeared first on Bloody Disgusting!.